In the just-concluded first leg of the UEFA Europa League quarterfinals, Manchester United were held to a frustrating 2-2 draw away to French side Lyon.
What should have been a crucial victory to lay the foundation for qualification was instead squandered—largely due to two catastrophic errors from goalkeeper André Onana, once again thrusting him into the spotlight for all the wrong reasons.
Attack Shows Promise, Defense Crumbles — Onana’s Nightmare Continues
This season, Manchester United have often struggled in attack, with strikers like Højlund and Zirkzee failing to deliver consistently.
However, this match saw a notable improvement in offensive output. Substitute Joshua Zirkzee came off the bench to score a late goal that seemed destined to hand United a valuable away win.
But just as the attacking unit showed signs of life, the defense — particularly Onana — completely collapsed when it mattered most.
Once again, the Cameroonian goalkeeper played the role of the “villain,” undoing his teammates’ efforts with two costly blunders.
Two Goals, Two Errors — Onana Cannot Escape the Blame
The first error came in the 25th minute! Lyon were awarded a free-kick on the left side of the pitch, which Thiago Almada floated into the box.
To the shock of everyone, the ball bounced untouched past several players and found the net.
Onana appeared completely unprepared, reacting slowly and failing to get a hand to what should have been a routine save.
Even if he claims his view was blocked or his attention diverted, a keeper at this level is expected to anticipate and react better in such scenarios.
But the second goal, in stoppage time, was far worse!
In the 95th minute, with United leading 2-1 and victory just seconds away, Onana spilled a relatively tame shot right in front of goal.
Lyon’s Rayan Cherki was on hand to pounce and tap in the equalizer, shattering United’s hopes of a critical away win.
This time, there were no excuses—just a blatant technical error from a goalkeeper who is supposed to instill confidence, not chaos.
Frustration Mounts — Manager Fumes as Onana Draws the Heat
Post-match reactions from United players were visibly filled with disappointment, and manager Chris Smalling did not hold back either.
Although he diplomatically stated that “the whole team shares responsibility,” it was clear to fans and pundits alike that Onana’s mistakes cost the team dearly.
It’s worth noting that Onana had already drawn attention before kickoff due to a war of words with former teammate Nemanja Matić, who labeled him “one of the worst goalkeepers in United history.”
Onana dismissed the criticism defiantly, but this performance only reinforced the growing narrative around his underwhelming stint at Old Trafford.
The Stats Don’t Lie — Onana’s Numbers Paint a Grim Picture
Since joining United in the summer of 2022, Onana has been a fixture between the posts—but not without constant controversy.
According to official statistics, he has now conceded 139 goals in just under two seasons, averaging a worrying 1.48 goals against per match.
This figure is among the worst for any regular United goalkeeper in the Premier League era, and even some backup keepers have posted better numbers.
While Onana was impressive in the Champions League with Inter Milan, he has failed to adapt to the pace and pressure of English football.
His shot-stopping, command of the box, and game management have all fallen short of the standards expected at a club like United.
Qualification Still Possible, but Warning Signs Flash Red
Despite the disappointing result, Manchester United still control their own destiny. A home win in the return leg at Old Trafford would be enough to see them through to the semifinals.
However, the warning signs are clear. With Onana’s form continuing to slide, relying on him in such a high-stakes match poses a significant risk. The coaching staff must seriously consider whether to start him again—or explore alternatives.
For supporters, one thing is certain: a team chasing European glory cannot afford a goalkeeper who repeatedly sabotages their chances.
A Win Thrown Away — A Bitter Reminder of a Deeper Problem
This 2-2 draw wasn’t just a missed opportunity—it was a win that was carelessly thrown away. United dominated large portions of the match and looked on course to take control of the tie, but two avoidable goals conceded through goalkeeping errors exposed a fundamental vulnerability.
As the decisive second leg looms, Manchester United have no more room for error. Their attacking line must continue firing, but equally important is the need for a goalkeeper who can rise to the occasion—not one who buckles under pressure.
Next week’s clash could prove to be the turning point not just for United’s European campaign—but for Onana’s future at the club as well. Whether it becomes his redemption arc or final chapter remains to be seen.
